Turtle Lake, North Dakota: The Wolf Family Murders of 1920

On April 22, 1920, someone entered a farmhouse three miles north of Turtle Lake, North Dakota, armed with a shotgun and a hatchet. By morning, eight people lay dead—seven members of the Wolf family and their teenage hired hand. Only eight-month-old Emma Wolf survived, left crying in her crib for two days while her family's bodies grew cold around her.

The Wolf family were German-Russian immigrants, part of a wave of settlers who had fled Tsarist oppression to build new lives on the Great Plains. Jacob Wolf had carved out a decent living on his quarter-section of land—fifty sheep, a two-story house, a wife named Beata, and seven daughters. They worshipped in German, kept to themselves, and measured success by how much land they could pass to the next generation.

Within twenty-four hours of the bodies being discovered, investigators focused on Henry Layer, a German-Russian neighbor who had been feuding with Jacob Wolf over a property dispute. What followed was called "the third degree"—prolonged interrogation involving sleep deprivation, physical abuse, and psychological pressure. After an all-night session, Layer confessed. But the confession would prove deeply problematic.

This episode examines one of North Dakota's darkest chapters: a case where the need for answers may have outweighed the pursuit of truth, where a tortured confession was accepted despite contradicting physical evidence, and where questions about what really happened that night have persisted for over a century.

Timeline of Events

The Wolf family murders represent one of the most brutal crimes in North Dakota history, occurring during a period when German-American communities faced intense scrutiny following World War I. Understanding the timeline reveals the troubling speed with which Layer was identified, interrogated, and convicted.

• April 22, 1920: The murders occur at the Wolf farmstead north of Turtle Lake
• April 24, 1920: Neighbor discovers the crime scene; eight-month-old Emma found alive after two days alone
• April 25, 1920: Henry Layer brought in for interrogation; confesses after all-night "third degree" questioning
• April 28, 1920: Mass funeral held at the Wolf farm; eight victims buried together
• May 1920: Layer's trial lasts three days; jury deliberates six hours before guilty verdict
• 1922: Layer's wife divorces him; North Dakota Supreme Court denies appeal
• June 1925: Layer dies in prison from appendicitis complications, maintaining questions about his sole guilt

Historical Significance

The Wolf family case illuminates troubling aspects of early twentieth-century American justice—particularly the widespread acceptance of coerced confessions as legitimate evidence. The "third degree" was standard police practice nationwide in 1920, with officers routinely using physical and psychological pressure to obtain confessions. Layer's interrogation, which left visible bruising and lasted through the night, was considered normal procedure.

The case also reflects the vulnerability of immigrant communities during periods of heightened nativism. German-Americans had faced persecution during World War I—lynchings, forced loyalty oaths, and bans on German-language schools. The German-Russian settlers around Turtle Lake knew what happened when communities became targets. Their need for closure, for someone to blame, may have contributed to accepting a confession that didn't fit the physical evidence.

Modern forensic analysis has raised serious questions about Layer's guilt. The angle of shotgun wounds suggested a shooter taller than Layer's five-foot-six frame. Blood spatter patterns indicated multiple attackers. The physical labor of moving six bodies was likely impossible for one person in the timeframe described. Boot prints at the scene didn't match Layer's footwear. Yet in 1920, a signed confession trumped forensic inconsistencies.

Emma Wolf, the sole survivor, was adopted by relatives and lived until 2003. She carried the weight of being "the Wolf girl" her entire life—a living reminder of a tragedy that shattered a community and left questions that may never be answered.

Sources & Further Reading

The Wolf family murders have been extensively documented through court records, newspaper archives, and historical research. Vernon Keel, a journalist who grew up near Turtle Lake, wrote "The Murdered Family," a work of historical fiction that reconstructs events based on legal records and family accounts.

• Prairie Public Broadcasting — "Death of Henry Layer" (Dakota Datebook series) provides verified historical timeline
• State Historical Society of North Dakota — Maintains archival photographs and court documents from the 1920 trial
• McLean County Museum (Washburn, ND) — Houses newspaper clippings and physical artifacts from the case
• "The Turtle Lake Murders" podcast by Forum Communications — Four-part investigation featuring interviews with Emma Wolf Hanson's son Curtis and forensic analysis

Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/hometownhistory/exclusive-content

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy