Unmasked 131: A Blanket, a Button, and a Body: The Curious Case of Katie DeWitt James

What starts as a road trip pit stop to Jungle Jim’s turns into a winding tale of escape rooms, eerie bathrooms, and a historical murder mystery that still haunts Oklahoma. In this episode of Mystery Inc., we’re joined by special guest Rick —true crime aficionado and Kim's sweet n low daddy —who regales us with the chilling 1905 disappearance of Katie DeWitt James.

From a chance encounter with a mysterious woman named Fannie Norton to a body found in the Canadian River, this century-old case is dripping with unanswered questions and forgotten truths. But don’t worry, we also make room for some hilarious tangents: Pat McAfee, Straight No Chaser, and the infamous “Do Not Push” button that nearly got us kicked out of an escape room.

If you like your true crime with a side of sass and a splash of sarcasm, this episode delivers.

In This Episode, We Cover:

• The bizarre events leading up to Katie DeWitt James’s disappearance
• Rick’s local insights into Oklahoma’s tornado alley and Twisters filming locations
• Cemetery legends and rodeo lore, including the tragic death of Lane Frost
• That time Shane almost guilt-tripped his way into a concert (spoiler: he didn’t go)

The emotional stakes of friendship, Facebook pranks, and Garth Brooks’ "Beaches of Cheyenne.”

Keywords:

Katie DeWitt James, Fannie Norton, 1905 Oklahoma murder, historical true crime, Canadian River body discovery, Lane Frost death, Twisters filming location, true crime comedy podcast, escape room mystery, Jungle Jim’s Ohio, Mystery Inc. podcast

Subscribe and follow Mystery Inc. for more haunting tales, laugh-out-loud detours, and the kind of mysteries that stick with you long after the episode ends.

Join us for Unmasked on Patreon.com/itsmysteryinc

Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/mystery-inc/exclusive-content

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy